Milky Chicken and a pie without pastry

For those of you that have read my blog before, you will know I put up my first ever meal plan post on Sunday. Meal planning is a regular occurrence in my house, unfortunately so is going slightly off-piste! Needing to write up those meals, plus day 13 of my Blogging101 course, meant I was looking for a food event to take part in. Lo and behold CookOnceEatTwice reared it perfect head. So here goes…..

Sunday was a Jamie Oliver inspired Chicken in Milk. Roasted in a tight fitting pot in milk, its weirdness intrigued me. I didn’t have any sage and decided to peel the garlic cloves but otherwise I pretty much stuck to the recipe.


1 Large Chicken
1 tbsp. Olive Oil
1/2 stick of cinnamon
Zest of 2 lemons
10 cloves garlic, peeled
1 pint milk

First of all find a pot that the chicken will fit into but be snug. Put oven on to pre-heat to Gas Mark 5. Heat the olive oil in your pan. At this point I attempted to brown the chicken but ended up with the skin sticking to the bottom of the pot, I think I should have stuck to my instinct and used butter. Having managed to brown some of the rest of the chicken without denuding it further, it is time to add all the rest of the ingredients to the pot (off the heat – you don’t want your milk boiling whilst you are still trying to zest your lemon) plus a good dash of black pepper.


Put the pot in the oven and cook for about an hour and a half – basting as and when you can, I turned my chicken half way through and basted it a couple of times. We had this instead of our usual gravy filled roast dinner. Good points – the chicken was really beautifully tender and moist. Bad points – I really didn’t like the sauce, I was expecting it to split the milk but we ended up with glop, it was tasty enough just not entirely to my taste.


Top tips and tweaks:

Use full fat milk instead of semi skimmed
Try adding some lemon juice as well as lemon zest
Or add the lemon slices to the cavity of the chicken
Try cream instead of milk
Add different herbs – thyme for example

So that’s the cook once bit done, what about the eat twice?  Well cold chicken is always useful, we have wraps and sandwiches for lunch but in the spirit of thriftiness I though I’d also add a second recipe with a little (but really not much) cooking to revitalise the leftovers.

This is where the meal plan went a bit off-piste (or off-plan at least). Monday was supposed to be pie and mash using something akin to this Chicken Pie recipe. So what went wrong? A power cut in the afternoon meant my kitchen was too dark to see properly and I couldn’t use my mixer to flake the butter into the flour. The Other Half had to travel to a local town for work and was going to be late home, so the Small Person and I popped into the local pub for Happy Hour – this involved a lot of chatting, being an hour later home than planned and me failing to make pastry for the pie. I hadn’t got any shop bought and I needed to make sure the Small Person ate at an appropriate time still.

And so we made pie without pastry, the pie filling made the way I had intended just without a shortcrust top. I almost regretted the lack of pastry as the filling was delicious (I got told off by Small Person for saving some for when Daddy got home – apparently she wanted his share). This recipe was doubly good for leftovers as not only did I use up most the leftover chicken (and there was still some for the Other Half to use in wraps and sandwiches for lunch) I also diced up some leftover vegetables. All quantities below are approximate – if you have no or very little left over vegetables, bulk out with an onion (fry with the bacon) or carrot for example.


25g butter
3 slices of bacon, chopped into small pieces
4 mushrooms, sliced
2 cups left over vegetables, finely diced
2 cups leftover chicken
150ml Double Cream
Pinch of black pepper


Fry off the bacon in the butter until it is starting to crisp and brown, then add the mushrooms, stir well so they coated in the oil. I have a saucepan lid that also fits my frying pan which I usually put on at this stage, it can keep the moisture coming out the mushrooms from evaporating yet. I like my mushrooms fairly well done and this stage certainly isn’t necessary, if using a lid remove after a couple of minutes, stir and let the mushrooms brown up too. Add in the diced veg, stir until they are warmed through and starting to brown before throwing in the chicken, once all combined, add the cream, make sure its on a low heat, grind in some pepper and then simmer for about 10 minutes until the chicken is thouroughly heated through. Serve with garlicky, cream mash (I added three garlic cloves when boiling my potatoes)


Top tips and tweaks:

Add pastry, I reckon this would be proper lush
If you don’t want to use cream – make a bechamel sauce

Experiment with adding herbs – I think tarragon would work really well with this


And in case you are wondering, I managed to stick to Tuesday’s plan, today’s is out the window! Please let me know your thoughts in the comments below, especially any other tweaks and tips



One thought on “Milky Chicken and a pie without pastry

  1. I think I’ve read that Jamie Oliver recipe and thought it sounded interesting but unusual. Not sure I’ll ever make it now! I love roast chicken though and it always makes a good meal with plenty of leftovers for the next day. Thank you so much for joining in with #CookOnceEatTwice!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave thoughts, tips, tweaks and general comments here:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s